Reparametrization Invariance, the controversial extraction of $\alpha$
from $B\to\pi\pi$ and New Physics
Francisco J. Botella (Valencia U. & Valencia U.
Miguel Nebot update to 2007-05-23
The extraction of the weak phase $\alpha$ from $B\to\pi\pi$ decays has beencontroversial from a statistical point of view, as the frequentist vs. bayesianconfrontation shows. We analyse several relevant questions which have notdeserved full attention and pervade the extraction of $\alpha$.Reparametrization Invariance proves appropriate to understand those issues. Weshow that some Standard Model inspired parametrizations can be senseless orinadequate if they go beyond the minimal Gronau and London assumptions: thesingle weak phase $\alpha$ just in the $\Delta I=3/2$ amplitudes, the isospinrelations and experimental data. Beside those analyses, we extract $\alpha$through the use of several adequate parametrizations, showing that there is norelevant discrepancy between frequentist and bayesian results. The mostrelevant information, in terms of $\alpha$, is the exclusion of values around$\alpha\sim \pi/4$; this result is valid in the presence of arbitrary NewPhysics contributions to the $\Delta I=1/2$ piece.